Wednesday, March 25, 2009

The Human Right to Water for All

In the discussion of universal human rights, there is nothing more basic than the human right to water. As one of the foundational needs of life, this issue is an ethical dilemma of global proportions. The human right to water pertains to sufficient, safe, accessible, and affordable water for all people. This basic right is recognized generally in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, (Article 3 — Right to life, liberty, and Personal Security; and Article 25 — Right to an Adequate Living Standard) and specifically recognized in various international treaties. However, we are in the midst of a water crisis of global proportions as the right to water is being eroded by the inclusion of water as commodity in other international trade treaties and conventions and as we face the effects of worsening climate change due to global warming, environmental pollution, and an increasing world population. As is often the case, it comes down to a matter of power, both political and economic, as the victims in the water crisis are generally poor, women, and racial and ethnic minorities.
The United Nations Development Program (UNDP) argues that the roots of the crisis can be traced to the issues of poverty and inequality and demonstrates how the lack of water creates cycles of poverty, gender inequity, disease and death. Unfortunately the international community has yet to make this issue a priority and so this basic human right is denied to millions of people. The issue is not the amount of water available; there is not a shortage of water. The issue rather is focusing attention on the extreme human toll of dirty water and inadequate sanitation which is the second largest killer of children worldwide, and creating a will to reverse the situation.
The current situation is sobering with millions of lives at stake. The situation grows worse by the day, especially in light of the effects of global warming. On March 12, 2009, thousands of climate scientists meeting in Copenhagen updated the findings of a 2007 report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ahead of U.N. talks in December on a new global climate treaty. Their conclusion issued a strong warning that global warming is accelerating beyond the worst predictions and threatens to trigger "irreversible" shifts on the planet. The shifts include changing rainfall patterns (in which dry areas become dryer and wet areas become wetter) an increase in extreme weather events and a drastic rise in sea levels. All these issues relate to the issue of water as a basic human right and will continue to grow in the future.
The hope for mitigating climate change (at least to some extent) lies in the de-carbonization of the global atmosphere and political will regarding this issue remains to be seen. Yet the cost to rectify the basic situation regarding access to clean, accessible and affordable water for all is relatively modest. It is estimated that 10 billion dollars would drastically improve access to water and sanitation for millions of people and save the lives of 1.8 million children annually. Although this price tag seems enormous, it equals what the world governments spend on military hardware alone every eight days. What is lacking is the will on the part of the international community to make this issue a top priority.
As Professor Amesbury states in Faith and Human Rights, “the biggest impediment to the realization in practice of human rights remains the lack of adequate mechanisms for enforcement.” (37) Amesbury notes further that the pressure of public opinion usually carries more weight than the threat of collective action. So where does that leave us? As a Unitarian Universalist who affirms the inherent worth and dignity of all people and understands the interdependent web of existence of we are but a part (our first and seventh principles), the issue of water as a basic human right is of utmost importance. Raising awareness about this issue and supporting efforts to prioritize water rights locally, statewide, nationally and globally is vital to making a change.

9 comments:

  1. This is a crucial issue, one which I am not fully versed on. Thank you for this overview, Tamara.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is an issue that is dear to my heart as I have devoted a significant chunk of time and energy to helping provide clean water in places that lack it. Thank you for bringing it to more people's attention.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Since, as you mention, public opinion is the biggest motivator of change, getting the word out is key. Thank you for taking the opportunity to do so.
    Two interrelated factors that need addressing come to mind here. First, I think of global warming and echo what you said, after listening to NPR's Science Friday program this week which explained the ways in which global warming is surpassing all scientific predictions. Global warming aggravates the water shortage and concomitant suffering. Aggravating global warming, in turn, is the growing population which you also touched on. Therefore, I believe that overpopulation should be addressed at the same time as the water shortage and environmental issues by also making birth control readily available to all who wish it, free of charge if necessary. My concern is that if humantiy does not willingly ocntrol its numbers, Nature (global warming) will do the job for it. The suffering from the water shortage and other crises would then increase exponentially. After all, to save the 1.8 million children who each year die from from thirst and disease, only to have the children that they, in turn, produce suffer, would be sadly counterproductive.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for adding to my education about this issue, Tamara. Reading your post brought to mind my interterm course with Dr. Slessarev-Jamir where we spent a week at the US-Mexico border. I remember our first day of the course when we traveled with the Human Borders volunteers to check the water tanks. As we traveled the open desert, I kept thinking about what it takes to just walk the desert floor for any length of time. It was sobering. When we got to the tanks and they told us that during the summer months they fill the two 100 gallon tanks 3x per week, I took note. Suddenly, my thought about walking the desert floor becaming chilling. We were at the northern most water station for Human Borders--a good three day walk from the border--and that's for someone in good health with the resources to take the trek. That then lead me to think about people across the world who live daily without access to potable drinking water at all. I can get overwhelmed with these types of situations and that's without the information you and others shared in your postings.

    However, what gets me going again is reading about people with financial resources who are building wells in Africa--not just giving out water bottles--but people working for sustainable solutions. I know that the sustainable solution of a well is compromised by not addressing global warming and population control. Yet, it is an action that provides relief for now for those people.

    Since we read King's letter, I've been thinking about what I can do at my local level to stand up and not wait for a situation to shift or eventually reach the desired resolution. It seems to me that the lack of potable water, a most fundamental requirement for a person's survival, is not a situation for which we can "wait" for the right time or the eventual shift to resolution. Waking up the world community remains key. We've seen results from the ONE campaign and people with financial resources who use their status and resources to work for sustainable change, such as Bono and the Gates Foundation.

    Since, as you've pointed out, there appears a strong link among global warming, population control, and water shortage, I'm wondering what would happen if public health and climate change gurus joined together with folks who have the public's attention. Seems like once an issue becomes personal to someone, things move . . .

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great topic Tamara. Well in the nation we live in this topic is not discussed too much. The reason being is we do not see immediate impact. Coming from what I have seen from the native land of my parents in Mumbai,India it is a topic of discussion. In a major metropolitan city like Mumbai there are water hours and water is stored in tanks for the entire day.
    In some parts of this world water may be available in the ground water table but there is no money to put a tubewell to tap this resource. About two weeks ago I was watching the news from Denver,Colorado where tap water could be ignited with a lighter. The reason was the acquifers were contaminated by Natural Gas. So indeed it is important that the enviromental impact be on our mind and we produce energy in a safe and efficient manner.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your topic hit very close to my heart. I grew up in an underdeveloped country and I know what it is like not to have water at your disposal. This is an epidemic of world wide portions and I’m glad you choose to address this issue.

    I would say that most people who are accustomed to the comforts of water take it for granted. It is only though educating people of the magnitude of this problem we may then be able to do something about it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tamara, I remembered you made a comment about your posting that got me interested. Although I did not come from an undeveloped nation or similar, I did grow up on a vineyard, where water is precious for the crops produced and profit made for the next year. The wierd thing was that there was canals that provided water to you and your neighbors, and you are supposed to water your crops on certain time periods, and people upstream could steal your allotted water by turning a valve. I completely agree about what you said Tamara, saying that the ability produce/harness clean water is a form of power/greed that few are aware of, and that those who are aware of the power don't want to share it with others.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Water, water everywhere and not a drop to drink! Not necessarily the case! Living in the southwest and being very aware that we are in an extended drought cycle, I agree partially with the statement there is plenty of water just the mismanagement of a this precious resource on the local and global scale. Ever since the United States Corps of Engineers began controlling the Colorado River to harness Hydro electricity and to sustain agriculture with this life giving substance we have been at odds with who gets the water and for what purpose.
    I have traveled the Colorado River by boat, canoe and inner tube. I have traveled to the Gulf of Baja where the river water practically stops after crossing the international border. I have watched the level of Lake Meade drop year after year during this season of drought and I have seen its waters diverted all the way to Los Angeles and to Tucson to build golf courses and plant non-native vegetation all in the name of meeting the needs of growing population.
    I guess I’m a little confused on our policies of water distribution when is has little to do with sustaining life (agriculture, clean industry) and is used more for unchecked growth and waste for questionable recreation purposes. To say that we have plenty of water for everyone has global sociological and anthropological implications. Do we now not only regulate growth in obviously drought stricken areas, and I am not even beginning to touch on the real poverty of drought in other areas of the world, or do we continue to shift resources to the peoples who have the greatest technology for transporting the resources away from their natural occurrence to where ever we decide to build metropolitan cities and unnatural types of ecological existence?
    Do we continue to wait for the change of ecological cycles that may take hundreds of years in coming?
    I guess I’m hoping that our belated interest in saving not only our planet, but our intrusion into the universe, leads us to more eco friendly relations with the environment.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I tend to think similarily to Robert. My home state of Utah has been dealing with drought for several years now yet it is still legal and custom for people to have lush green lawns, which is not natural for the Utah climate. Almost everywhere you go there are golf courses and businesses with those little patches of grass between the parking lot and the street that serve no real purpose except custom. These lawns are constantly being watered during the middle of the hot summer day when the water is most likely going to be evaporated instead of absorbed into the ground. Additionally my route back and forth between Utah and Claremont goes straight through Las Vegas. I know I might offend some when I say this but I HATE Las Vegas. I consider it a huge waste of resources. And when I say this I am mainly refering to the strip, not the residential areas of which I know nothing about. But the strip only exists for entertainment. Water is used for fountains, pools, and hotels all of which exist in the middle of the desert. And much of this water is being pumped over from Utah leaving behind a drastic water shortage. I hear so much lately about water shortage and yet I see so much of it being wasted on luxury. It seems to me that one way to get people to start saving on water is to challenge their notions of acceptable landscaping and recreational activities.

    ReplyDelete